Thursday, January 12, 2012

Latest Argument Before the Second Court of Appeals

I argued an interesting case on Tuesday before the Court of Appeals for the Second Judicial District of Texas in Fort Worth.  It's posted here for your listening pleasure.  It was a driving while intoxicated case with issues regarding the sufficient of the evidence, the trial court's ruling on a motion to suppress evidence, and defining the term "operate" in the jury charge.

Arguing at the Court of Appeals is very different than trial work.  The Court of Appeals is much more formal and structured.  There is not a jury.  Argument takes place in a courtroom behind a podium and in front of three justices.  If you are the appellant, as I was in this case, then by local rule, you have 15 minutes to argue.  There are small green, yellow, and red lights to warn you when you have used up certain amounts of time and when you have to stop speaking (even mid-sentence you have to stop if the red light comes on).  Then, the appellee, the state of Texas in this case, gets 15 minutes to argue.  Finally, the appellant (me) gets 5 minutes for rebuttal argument.  The justices can (and do) interrupt at any time to ask questions about case law, the record, anything really.  One of the most frustrating things for me is that you don't get a ruling right away.  It takes several months for the court of appeals to write and issue an opinion on a case.  

Arguing before the court of appeals is unlike anything I've done.  You have to be on your toes at all times, and it is imperative that you know the pertinent case law and record inside and out.  I believe being an appellate lawyer makes me a better trial lawyer.  I know exactly what to do and how to preserve the record at trial, and I believe being a good appellate lawyer gives me credibility with the trial court judges when I am arguing the law.

Happy listening, and I will be sure to post when the opinion comes out - fingers crossed!

Wednesday, November 30, 2011

Everyone Needs to Watch This...


The Fifth Amendment gives us all the right to remain silent.  Let's use it.  All the time.  Please.  Even if you are innocent, use it.  Even if it's just a traffic violation, use it.  

Here is a non-exclusive list of some things you may not know about police interrogations which should be reason enough to exercise your right to remain silent:
  1. the police can lie to you...and often will in order to get you to confess (they can tell you they have it all on tape when in actuality they don't, for instance)
  2. the police are trained in psychological interrogation techniques designed to elicit confessions (the Reid Technique)
  3. the police only want to talk to you because they already, at the very least, suspect you're involved in the crime in some way
  4. you are being audio and video taped...even if you don't see the camera
  5. the police don't have to give you Miranda warnings if you are not in custody and not being interrogated - that means if you go to the police department on your own thinking you are doing the right thing you will not be warned about your constitutional protections prior to police questioning
  6. the police don't have to tell you what they know...and usually won't
  7. the police know how to manipulate what you say - you will not outsmart the police (you are not Dexter)
  8. the police are getting paid to question you therefore they have no motivation to end the questioning - you, on the other hand, will want to leave as quickly as you can
  9. their goal is to get a confession even if it's not for the original offense they started questioning you about
  10. you will not be able to lie and get away with it
  11. you will not be able to talk your way out of an arrest
So, what do you do?  Knowledge is power.  Know your rights.  There is a way to politely and intelligently deal with the police.  Always be polite, but always be firm when speaking with the police.  For instance, "yes, I will talk to you if I can have my lawyer here"; "no, you cannot search my car"; "no, you cannot come into my house", etc.   

You can expect to be verbally bullied when you give this response, but stick to your guns.  Be firm.  Seasoned, intelligent police officers will be disappointed in this response but they will understand it and won't be offended by it.  After all, they know their role, and they know your constitutional rights.  You might as well know your rights too, and exercise them!   


Monday, November 28, 2011

Who Wants to Live in Oceania....Perhaps We Already Are

Well, Texas has done it again.  We are in yet another very exclusive category...even within our own nation.  Texas is only 1 of 4 states that allow deliberate familial DNA searches.  The other 3 are California, Colorado, and Virginia.

With the saturation of television crime scene dramas everyone these days know about standard forensic DNA testing.  This involves seeking a direct match between DNA found at a crime scene and the DNA of a suspect.  With the advent of the FBI database, CODIS (Combined DNA Index System), in 1998 DNA searches have become a constant reality.  It is now a standard condition of felony probation in most counties, including Denton, that the probationer submit a DNA sample for CODIS.  It seems harmless enough after all - just a swab of the cheek and that condition can be marked off the list. But is it really harmless...?

Familial DNA searches, on the other hand, implicate broader privacy concerns.  Familial DNA searches are searches for a close relative's DNA.  They are used when a "suspect" has thus far avoided the "cheek swab" that comes along with any sort of felony disposition (other than an acquittal of course) making the suspect's DNA unavailable to law enforcement.  Familial DNA searches are useful because, according to Time Magazine, 48% of people in jail have a relative who has also been incarcerated. 
It may be a good investigative tool and pass constitutional muster in the end.  But before jumping on board with familial DNA searches it's worth thinking about.  Now, how many people will unknowingly be under constant genetic surveillance?  Isn't this just something else that makes it all seem a bit too Orwellian??

Thursday, November 17, 2011

Beyond Comprehension

When you think about it, it's amazing really.  In Texas, a person can be mentally retarded yet competent - competent yet insane.  Does that even make sense?  

Not too terribly long ago, in Atikins v. Virginia, the US Supreme Court ruled that a mentally retarded person could not be executed - it's a violation of the 8th Amendment prohibition against cruel and unusual punishment.  (It's a whole separate issue that it took the United States, one of the most civilized countries in the entire world, until 2002 to come to this realization).  However, a mentally retarded person can be put to trial for a criminal act...an intentional or knowing criminal act...and a mentally retarded person can be sentenced to prison - even life in prison.  After all, a mentally retarded person, by definition, has significantly impaired cognitive functioning and deficits in two or more adaptive behaviors.  

Confused?

In Texas, in order to be competent a person simply has to have a sufficient present ability to consult with the person's lawyer with a reasonable degree of rational understanding and a rational as well as faction understanding of the proceedings against him.  Further, in Texas there is a presumption of competency.

What then of the mentally retarded whom psychologists deem competent?  Once a mentally retarded yet technically competent person is subjected to the criminal justice system, chances are that he will forever be a statistic in the criminal justice system absent a loving family or some other source of support.  I certainly don't pretend to have all of the answers but there must be a better solution than just warehousing people...mentally retarded people.  It is simply beyond comprehension...

Friday, November 11, 2011

Persistence is Key

As a criminal defense lawyer you get used to being told "no" by prosecutors.  No, your guy can't have probation.  No, we won't waive a jury.  No, we won't agree to a bond reduction.  Some prosecutors seem to get mad just because you ask the question (that's a whole separate post for another day).  More often than not, criminal defense lawyers are told "no."

And that's fine.  It's part of the territory.  After all, that's what courtrooms and juries are for - to sort it all out when there is no agreement.  However, it doesn't mean that you should stop asking the question just because you have been told "no."

This week was a prime example of persistence paying off.  After asking countless times since June and being told "no," I was finally told "okay."  (not a firm yes, mind you, but a relenting "okay").  And it mattered to my client and his parents.  It means that an enhancement allegation was waived and now he will not be required to do at least half of his time before he becomes eligible for parole.  A minor victory in the grand scheme of things but a major win for a client.

Yes, persistence is the key in a world of no's.

Sunday, October 23, 2011

Food for Thought...

Last month Texas stopped providing requested last meals to prisoners prior to execution.  This was prompted by death row inmate, Russell Brewer, who ordered an elaborate last meal and then, in an act of defiance (or maybe he just wasn't hungry anymore) did not eat anything prepared.  Now, death row prisoners will receive the same meal as the rest of the prisoners as their last.

According to the New York Times, in a bid to further cut costs some Texas Prisons have resorted to not providing lunch on weekends to prisoners.  That's fine, though at some point there is sure to be a constitutional challenge and civil rights lawsuit.  And there will be undoubtedly be a further division even in the prison population between the classes - those who have money on their books and those who do not.

Thursday, September 8, 2011

SNAKE BIT!!!

Labor Day weekend was exciting for me!  Sunday morning started as normal - early church, water the plants at the office, and then home.  Because it was such a nice day Josh, my husband, and I worked in the yard.  We started redoing a flower bed, pulling up all the old, dead, burnt up plants and replacing them.  I was pulling weeds.  I reached in to pull the weeds from a bed and I felt an intense, sharp pain.  

At first I thought it was a bee sting, but it was WAY more intense.  I saw two specks, and I mean specks, of blood.  I ran inside to wash it off, and I immediately felt faint.  It was surging through my whole body.  My husband came in right after me, and loaded me in the car saying it was a copperhead snake.  What?!  I grew up in the country and never got bitten!  

We made it there in less than 15 minutes from the bite.  That, the doctors say, is what saved my finger and hand...his quick reaction.  Below are a couple of the pictures from the ER.  Somehow, I forgot about a camera after I was wheeled into ICU.  I am happy to report that after 2 days in ICU and another in a regular room my finger, hand, and I will be fine...eventually...and with a story to tell!



Below are pictures taken today, 2 days after being released from the hospital.  I still can't straighten it, and it's still pretty swollen.  However, wouldn't you agree that it looks much better now?!